I only gave 2 stars because everything fits in there. Good fit too not too big I take a size 6. I am very pleased with these sandals, I usually get leather ones but I couldnt find any in this size so I went for these instead, which were also cheaper. I am thinking the latter, because this is not the only review this happened with. I got a pair for free on a flight a few years ago, and they finally gave out. I attempted screwing it together without and go basically nowhere. I find this confusing as Ive been very pleased with all of the other Gatco brand fixtures Ive purchased, including the Elevate Hotel Style Towel Rack (same collection as this one). I immediately jumped on it when it was delivered. I took it on one river float and it stopped turning on. In the words of my wife, "my inexpensive DEARFOAM slippers have all their stitching in tact after years? Very disappointing, I almost never write reviews but think its important other people arent disapointed like we are.